On luggage ribbons, status symbols and the curious difference between being recognised and being known.
Nobody looks their best at a baggage carousel at six in the morning. Two hundred people who’ve just shared ten hours of recycled air and one tiny bathroom stand shoulder to shoulder, staring at a set of rubber flaps as though they’re about to read out the lottery numbers. The belt starts with a lurch, the flaps part, and the first case appears: a black wheeled suitcase of medium size. Every single person in the hall leans forward slightly, because it might be theirs. It isn’t. Neither is the next one, which is also black, also wheeled and also of medium size, and neither are the forty after that, which are, too.
So much for individuality.
Seasoned travellers know the trick, of course. You tie something to the handle so you can spot your case from across the hall: a ribbon, a pompom, a luggage strap in a pattern so cheerful it could only belong to you. Then you stand at the carousel and watch the belt come round, and every case on it has a ribbon. There are red ones and green ones, tartan straps and leopard print tags, a small felt flamingo, and at least three cases wearing exactly the same quirky strap from exactly the same shop at the departures end of the same airport.
Each owner looks at the others with the faint sense of betrayal of someone who has just discovered they aren’t the only person on earth who likes flamingos. (For my American friends, the same scene plays out at every baggage claim from JFK to LAX, only with more elbows and one unclaimed case doing laps for forty minutes.)
Nobody at the carousel is being foolish. The ribbon is a perfectly sensible answer to a real problem, which is that we’d all quite like to be able to find what’s ours in a crowd. The difficulty is that everybody else has the same problem, and the shop at the departures end only stocks so many answers. That, more or less, is the individuality uniform, and once you’ve seen it at the carousel you start seeing it everywhere else.
The Ribbon Problem
Walk down any high street, or scroll for thirty seconds, and you’ll find individuality for sale in bulk. There are tote bags printed with “be yourself” in their thousands, the same “statement” trainers on every third pair of feet, the same watch on the same wrist, and the same unexpected accent wall in the same shade of green in what feels like every living room in the country. All of them are sold to us as a way of showing who we really are, and all of them are bought by everyone else for exactly the same reason.
The easy conclusion is that we’ve all lost our originality somewhere along the way, and that we’re a nation of sheep in matching gilets. I don’t think that’s it, and I don’t think it’s fair. Wanting to be recognisable isn’t the same thing as wanting to be the same. The person tying the flamingo to her suitcase isn’t trying to blend in. She’s trying to be found. At the carousel, the ribbon only has to be recognisable to her.
Out in the wider world, though, the things we choose to distinguish ourselves with often have another job: telling other people something about who we are. And for that, they have to speak a language somebody else can read. The trouble is that the vocabulary is remarkably limited.
So we choose our distinctiveness from a shortlist the market has already printed, and we do it for reasons that are far more interesting, and rather more tender, than vanity.
What the Ribbon Is Really For
When I was researching the pathologies of worth, the people I interviewed talked a great deal about wanting “nice things”, and for a while I took that at face value. What I came to understand was that the nice things weren’t really the point. They worked as a signal, a breadcrumb trail of clues left out for other people about how you were doing, readable at a glance by anyone passing, and far easier to show than to say.
They also did two jobs at once, which is the bit I find most fascinating. A visible sign of doing well said I belong here, I’m one of the people who are managing, and in the very same breath it said and I’ve done better than you’d have expected of someone like me. Belonging and standing apart, bought in one transaction and carried on one handle.
I know this from the inside, too, and I’d rather say so than pretend otherwise. I wrote in my research diary at the time: “I worked, had a house, drove a car. I wanted people to think I could cope.” Reading it back now, I recognise that car for exactly what it was, which was a ribbon. It wasn’t there to impress anybody so much as to be legible, a sign in a language everyone on my street already spoke, saying that this one was doing alright, thank you, and there was no need to look any closer.
I’ve written before about how this plays out across a family dining table on a Sunday, where the new car gets parked so it can be seen from the window. The carousel is the wider version of the same thing, where the audience isn’t one person whose approval you’re waiting for but more or less everyone.
The Gift Shop at the Exit
You’ll have noticed that almost every remarkable experience now ends in the same place. You walk the castle, the canyon rim, the aquarium or the house where somebody famous once wrote something, and then a sign directs you, with great politeness and no alternative, through the gift shop. There you’ll find the same fridge magnet, the same tote bag, the same mug with the same slightly startled illustration. And you’ll buy one, because the experience was wonderful and you’d like to bring a piece of it home. The souvenir is a sort of receipt; proof you went, readable by anyone who sees it on your fridge.
Photographs have become the biggest gift shop of all, and I’m as fond of mine as anyone. When I posted pictures of our road trips across the United States and New Zealand, I posted them for the reason most people do, which is that something wonderful had happened and I wanted to share it. What came back, more than once, was lucky. It used to get my back up, I’ll admit, because what sat behind those photographs was marking until three in the morning, writing while the house slept and, at times, a second job on top of the first.
But nobody who said it was being unkind. They were doing what all of us do with other people’s souvenirs, reading the picture and missing the bill, because nights at a kitchen table don’t photograph and a sunset over an empty road does. I’ve done exactly the same to other people more times than I could count. In You Couldn’t Make This Up (But I Did. Repeatedly.), I explored the life behind the snapshot. This is the other side of it: what the snapshot can never carry, however hard it tries.
That’s the quiet trouble with a world where so much of our worth gets read from what we display. The display is never the whole story, and the people reading it fill in the rest with whatever they already believe, about luck, about privilege, about people like us. The meaning of a thing you show stops belonging to you the moment you show it.
Different in Exactly the Same Way
If recognisable signals are so easily misread, you might wonder why more of us don’t simply strike out on our own, with a suitcase covered in something nobody has ever seen. The honest answer, I think, is that a truly original signal carries a risk that has very little to do with being disliked. The risk is being unreadable. People can usually manage to disapprove of something they recognise, but something they can’t place makes them uneasy, and unease has a way of turning into distance. So we package our individuality into forms other people already know how to value, not because we’ve run out of imagination, but because being understood has always felt safer than being mysterious.
It’s a different thing from buying the person you’d like to become, which I wrote about in The Prophecy of the Untouched Yoga Mat, where the treadmill was mostly for the version of you who might one day use it. The ribbon is for the audience. And it’s a cousin of the crowd I described in Independent Thinking, the one that all turns up wearing the same leather jacket in the name of standing apart. The difference here is that nobody is policing the ribbons. We choose them all by ourselves, quite cheerfully, because they work.
Nobody at the Carousel Is Doing It Wrong
None of this is an argument for cutting the ribbons off. Shared tastes can be perfectly genuine, and four women turning up in the same dress doesn’t make them the same woman. You’re allowed to love the flamingo, the watch, the green wall and the photograph of the sunset, and loving something that thousands of other people also love doesn’t cancel out the loving.
What’s worth noticing is who a thing is for. Some of what we carry is for us, because it reminds us of somewhere or simply makes the walk through arrivals a little more cheerful. Some of it is for the reading, there to tell strangers something about us we’d rather not have to say out loud. Most of it, if we’re honest, is a bit of both. And that’s fine.
Awareness doesn’t mean auditing your luggage. It means occasionally catching yourself at the till, or with your thumb over the post button, and asking quietly whether you’re choosing this or being chosen by the shortlist. And it means, the next time lucky forms on your tongue in front of someone else’s photographs, wondering for a moment what bill you can’t see.
The Case Only You Can Carry
In my research there was a moment I came to call the knowing point. It’s the moment when a person stops waiting for everyone else to read them correctly and decides, more or less on their own authority, that they know what they’re worth. It rarely arrived with any fanfare, and it didn’t depend on owning anything in particular. It simply meant the evidence no longer needed an audience. Perhaps that’s the quieter side of individuality: knowing what matters to you when there’s nobody watching.
That’s the part the gift shop can’t sell you, and the ribbon can’t announce. The ribbon helps you find your case on the belt, which is useful at six in the morning and not to be sniffed at. But it was never the thing that made the case yours. That was always what you packed in it, the weight of it in your hand, and the fact that you know, without looking, which one you’re going home with.
If you’ve ever wondered how much of yourself you arrange around being understood, there’s another question worth exploring: what happens when being accepted starts to depend on being agreeable? The Cost of Nice offers a closer look at the small accommodations we make, the expectations that grow around them and what they can quietly cost us. It’s free and takes around fifteen minutes.
NyxDrop™: The ribbon is for the strangers. You already know which case is yours.
With thanks to Justanotherreader, whose question on Substack about why everything has started to look the same sparked this piece.